So, after a week of phone calls back and forth with the website LetsTalk.com and some phone calls to T-Mobile, I finally have a cell phone again.
Let's recap what I thought of LetsTalk.com. I think the company should be renamed to LetsNotGetYourHopesUpBeforeWeTalk.com. Don't believe the "Two Day" shipping promise, unless you have the plainest, no complications possible activation scenario. I had a contract with T-Mobile over two years ago, and this is naturally still in their system. So when Let's Talk sent my information for a credit check, they got an "Account Already Exists" error. They didn't tell me for over two days, so when I finally got the email saying there was a problem, it was Monday. The email instructed me to call T-Mobile to "reactivate" my account. Problem was it's been over two years, and my phone facts are different now than they were when I had the account (different number, different area, different usage plan, etc...). I call T-Mobile, explain the situation, and the guy says "Yes, I see your account. No, it doesn't have any issues. You need to call Let's Talk and have them process your order as normal." So I do.
Two days later, same issue. So I call T-Mobile first, and the woman was awesome. She actually called Let's Talk on my behalf and got my order moving. Kudos to her! Then I called Let's Talk, where they told me, "It's going under review, everything should be moving within 24 hours." Next day, I got an email saying my account was approved, and they expected to ship my phones on AUGUST 31 (I ordered on August 24).
I called Let's Talk back, explained that this had been going on for a week, and that if I had just gone to the store I would have left with a phone the same day. Waiting over a week and a half for a phone was unacceptable. To their credit, the CSR talked with a manager and said they would try to expedite my shipping.
And they did. It went out later that evening, and the details said Stacie's number had been ported correctly. However, my number was a completely different story--it looked like someone had mis-typed my actual number by shifting their hand one row of keys up on the number pad. I checked my original order, and I input my number correctly, so the error was on Let's Talk. So, Call Number 5 to Let's Talk Customer Service, where the lady said they would put out an activation error flag on my account and the issue should be fixed within 24 hours.
Stacie got the phones are around noon on Friday (which was good, because her phone number ported correctly the night before). She followed the T-Mobile instructions to check which phone was which and noticed my number was beyond FUBAR--it wasn't even the number Let's Talk told me was ported! Call Numbers 6 & 7 (I think the lady accidentally disconnected me the first time). Call Number 6's note read "Informed customer incident has not been open 24 hours; issue will be resolved with in that time frame." So, I waited.
When I got home, my number magically was ported. So, when Let's Talk said they would do something, they did it. But, not at a pace that is really acceptable in today's world. I also have strong concerns about their ability to make money as I understand their business model. I know they get commissions or referral fees for signing up customers and doing contract negotiations, but they received nothing for the merchandise they sent me, and I had 7 (!) calls to the customer service line. If every order works like that, they can't possibly stay afloat!
One thing I noticed, too, that there wasn't full disclosure when I ordered the phones. The $50 additional rebate (so, basically, I get paid to order these phones) only works if you keep the phones for at least one billing cycle, and you have to submit proof of payment of your first bill. That's fine, I understand that you can't pay us if you don't get paid, but that should be written somewhere before I order the phones thinking I can submit a rebate form as soon as I receive them.
Overall... The phones are a good buy (a steal, really), and the customer service was adequate. The actual service of buying the phones? Well, that left something to be desired. Would I do this again? Now that I have better informed expectations, actually, I would. But I would not expect to receive my merchandise in a matter a days, and I would make absolutely certain I had access to another method of communication during the time my order is being processed and/or shipped. They get 3 stars out of five (I just made up my own rating system) because the products are good, the customer service was good, but the service itself and full disclosure of how the process worked left something to be desired. I should not have had to call customer service seven times to get the process moving and to stay informed, but at least when I called customer service, the reps knew what they were talking about, were helpful, and were nice. Just understand that you get what you pay for when you order a less than free phone from a distributor whose business model is making money by paying you for using their business.